What happens when reformed theology meets heavy music? We sat down with Plead the Widow's Cause — a spirit-filled post-hardcore band — to talk idolatry, Isaiah, and why one Old Testament story might just be the most metal moment in the entire Bible.
In this episode of Deformed Theology (Ep. 53), Jonathan and David sit down with the full band — Ian, Bill, Brett, and Mitch — for an honest, theologically rich conversation about faith, the music they make, and what it means to stand up for those without a voice. Topics we cover:
How "spirit-filled post-hardcore" was born and who influenced it (Overcome, Unashamed, early Under Oath)
The band's reformed Baptist roots — and how all four members got there from very different backgrounds
The biblical stories behind their song "Marah" — idolatry, bitter waters, and Dagon falling face down before the Ark of the Covenant
Why their band name comes from Isaiah 1:17 and what it means to be the voice for the voiceless
The rise of individualism and narcissism — and how it distorts our view of God
Updates on their new 12-song album and their upcoming set at Audio Feed Festival (July 3rd)
Mitch's one-man side project, Pipe Bomb
"It's not about theological argument — it's about casting down every idol and walking under the Lordship of Christ."
🎵 Check out Plead the Widow's Cause: https://pleadthewidowscause.bandcamp.com/music
🎙️ Subscribe for new episodes every Monday at 5AM Central
📖 Scripture of the episode: Isaiah 1:17 | Colossians 3
00:00 Introduction and Context Setting
01:12 The Rapture Debate
04:10 Band Origins and Formation
05:10 Theological Backgrounds of the Band Members
08:01 Songwriting Process and Inspirations
11:11 Exploring the Album: Mara and Its Themes
14:11 The Meaning Behind the Band Name
16:54 Cultural and Personal Influences on Faith
20:03 Concluding Thoughts on Deformed Theology
25:31 The Rise of Individualism and Its Impact on Faith
29:03 Idolatry in Modern Christianity
31:24 The Battle Against Cultural Idolatry
32:05 Upcoming Music Projects and Performances
38:19 The Birth of Pipe Bomb: A Solo Project
44:00 Future Plans and Closing Thoughts